BVL and JRC focus on early recognition of food crises

FQN attended the BVL and JRC symposium in Berlin

How data can be used for prevention, consumer perception of risk and early warning systems were highlighted in summary remarks by the president of the BVL.

Dr Helmut Tschiersky said there was not one standard consumer but different types that have different information needs and the method of delivery needs to be adapted to the different groups.

He added future challenges include finding a way to combine knowledge in one central network to have prevention in co-ordinated way.

The symposium was hosted by the Federal Office of Consumer Protection and Food Safety (Bundesamt für Verbraucherschutz und Lebensmittelsicherheit, BVL) and the European Commission’s Joint Research Centre (JRC) in Berlin.

Philippe Loopuyt, DG SANTE, European Commission said food authenticity is to become a European Union Reference Laboratory (EURL) in the update of official control regulation finalised next year.

EURLs coordinate national reference laboratories (NRLs) in getting results through reference methods and materials, proficiency testing schemes and training to laboratory staff.

Authorities and company monitoring systems

The first part saw Dr Holger Brackemann of Stiftung Warentest and Matthias Wolfschmidt from foodwatch give talks focussing on the interests of consumers.

The second session had Dr Jens Linge, JRC, European Commission presenting the algorithms behind MedISys, Dr Hans Marvin of RIKILT on an early warning system to detect, predict and assess food fraud and Dr Petra Luber, BVL telling attendees about BeoWarn - BVL's warning system for crisis prevention.

Dr Linge said it is monitoring Twitter and Facebook in addition to traditional media such as BBC feeds as well as patents and scientific literature.

He added MedISys will be enhanced further to include adverse effects, consumer products, food and feed.

Dr Tobin Robinson explained how members can raise an issue in the European Food Safety Authority’s Emerging Risks Exchange Network (EREN).

They create what is known as a briefing note which goes around the network and gathers information and opinion and at some point it has enough for a decision to be made to make a risk assessment or prioritise data research.

Dr Robinson said climate change is not theoretical and can pose a risk to food safety.

He said invasive species can bring new diseases such as ciguatera from fish contaminated with toxin produced by algae and other species starting to appear in European waters.

Dr Richard Stadler, of Nestlé, said one up and one down traceability in the supply chain is not enough.

Its early warning network consists of supplier quality assurance such as vendor audits, performance monitoring, factory quality control including NIR fingerprinting, sensory and proximate analysis and it has looked at systems such as MALDI-TOF, multiplexing and rapid test kits.

Dr Stadler said he would welcome more working together as safety standards change and new scientific knowledge emerges on known contaminants instead of using ALARA (as low as reasonably achievable).

He added all parties have a common interest – to safeguard the food supply – whether it is through upstream testing with faster, cheaper screening tools or a focus on internationally recognised methods and method alignment to help avoid compliance issues and trade disputes.

A look at food crime

Andy Morling from theNational Food Crime Unit said food crime is when food fraud becomes serious in terms of detriment to consumers and financial gain or scope.

He said intelligence in the UK suggested true organised crime was a ‘very, very small part’ in food crime but it cannot afford to be complacent as a regulatory non-complier can become a fraudster.

“If legitimate players see food criminals gaining market share, they are at a competitive disadvantage, so why should they comply?” he told attendees.

Morling said there are a range of vulnerabilities citing cattle movements being mis-described to gain a higher quality status on welfare standards, so supermarkets pay a higher price and consumers also pay more than the meat justifies.

Cheese was one of the most vulnerable subjects the unit had seen so far, with one example being a dairy product with an additive it should not have, making it look different and gain market share.

Morling said another issue was product destined for destruction finding its way back into chain with the company entrusted with its disposal putting it back onto the market via relabelling or re-dating expired meat products.

The issue is more prominent in the meat industry than elsewhere but Morling said this could be as it is being looked for more and there are better infrastructures to detect it, so a degree of confirmation bias comes into play.

He added there was a need for more severe penalties as a deterrent but it looks to prosecute for fraud rather than breaches of food law as the law is there for a stronger punishment.

Related News

©iStock/Tadeusz Wejkszo

Alcohol issues cited in JRC fraud summary


Italy dominates JRC fraud summary

©iStock/Fleckus. Mett is minced raw pork popular in Germany

Pork still ‘significant’ source of infection with Salmonella - BVL


JRC drops rights to host three EURLs from next year


JRC finds 14% of honey samples to be adulterated

Red Snapper fish fillet from Vietnam was linked to 11 illnesses earlier this year in Germany. Picture: ©iStock/CreditPicturePartners

EU project tackles increase in ciguatera fish poisoning

FQN at BVL, EHEDG and RME in next few weeks. ©iStock/06photo

FQN hits the road to bring you food safety news

Proteste, a Brazilian consumer association, found issues with olive oil in quality tests

Fish and wine in Italy feature in JRC summary on food fraud

European Commission funds EURLS work programme

EU Reference Laboratories support for 2016/17 revealed

BfR hosted the Food Law Enforcement Practitioners conference on the topic

Increasing requirements on food authentication - BfR

JRC said the CRMs will improve reliability of measuring SEA in cheese at sub nanogram/gram levels

JRC develops CRMs to detect enterotoxin A in cheese

Frozen strawberries were the vehicle for the outbreak

Action on Norovirus outbreak stopped ‘double the cases’

Related Products

See more related products

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.